Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026_06_23 Board MinutesMEETING MINUTES Attendance Voting Members Hillary Radcliffe, Chair Paul Haacke, Vice Chair - Remote Kristy Mickelsen, Trustee Shay Ricks, Trustee Jeremy Westwood, Trustee - Remote Non-Voting Members Karla LaOrange, Superintendent Jessica Cushman, Executive Assistant to the Superintendent and Board Clerk 1. EXECUTIVE SESSION 4:00 PM A. Executive Session [IDAHO CODE §74-206 (1)(b) Personnel] Due to waiting for a quorum, at 4:09 pm Chairwoman Radcliffe called for a motion to go into Executive Session. Trustee Ricks made a motion to go into Executive Session IDAHO CODE §74-206 (1)(b) Personnel]. Trustee Haacke provided the second. Trustee Mickelsen joined remotely at 4:45 pm. Board of Trustees met in Executive Session to discuss personnel matters. The Executive Session concluded at 4:52 pm. Motion made by: Shay Ricks Motion seconded by: Paul Haacke Voting results: Yes: Hillary Radcliffe Yes: Paul Haacke Not Present: Kristy Mickelsen Yes: Shay Ricks Yes: Jeremy Westwood 2. WORK SESSION A. Call To Order Work Session is called to order at 4:54 pm by Chairwoman Radcliffe. Board Work Session 06/23/2026 - 04:00 PM District Office 690 John Adams Pkwy Idaho Falls,ID 83401 1 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D B. Adopt Agenda Chairwoman Radcliffe requested a motion to adopt the agenda. Trustee Ricks made a motion to adopt the agenda. Motion made by: Shay Ricks Motion seconded by: Paul Haacke Voting results: Yes: Hillary Radcliffe Yes: Paul Haacke Not Present: Kristy Mickelsen Yes: Shay Ricks Not Present: Jeremy Westwood 3. WORK SESSION BUSINESS Trustee M ickelsen joined in person at 5:05 pm. A. Levy Presentation Levy Presentation was provided by Eric Heringer of Piper Sandler, which is attached to the board minutes. Nick M illler and Brandon Helgeson also joined to provide information regarding levy language. Superintendent LaOrange and Lanell Farmer, Director of Finance, provided recommendations for the board to consider for a potential levy. The Board discusses additional information needed prior to the next work session to continue the discussion for a potential levy. SD 91 Levy Overview_6.23.26 B. Board Policy Superintendent LaOrange reviews recommended policy for Public Gifts/Donations to the Schools and Use of District Property. 4500 Public GiftsDonations to the Schools Use of District Property C. Superintendent Evaluation Jayson Lloyd from the Idaho School Board Association presented training information on the Superintendent Evaluation. He provides this information to help update the current Superintendent Evaluation process. The Board discusses formulating a new evaluation form in the August meeting. 2 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D 4. ADJOURN Chairwoman Radcliffe requested a motion to adjourn. Trustee Ricks made a motion to adjourn. Meeting adjourned 6:35 pm. Motion made by: Shay Ricks Motion seconded by: Kristy Mickelsen Voting results: Yes: Hillary Radcliffe Not Present: Paul Haacke Yes: Kristy Mickelsen Yes: Shay Ricks Not Present: Jeremy Westwood 3 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D Supporting Documents The following PDFs were attached to the minutes: 3. A. Levy Presentation SD 91 Levy Overview_6.23.26 3. B. Board Policy 4500 Public GiftsDonations to the Schools Use of District Property 4 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D June 23, 2026 Idaho Falls School District No. 91 Levy Review Eric Heringer MANAGING DIRECTOR+1 208-344-8561eric.heringer@psc.com 01 School District Levy Overview Piper Sandler |3 Overview of Voted Levies Piper Sandler |4 SD 91 Election History Date of Election Election Type % Approval Pass/ Fail Amount Term/ Duration 11/17/2009 Bond 56.33%Fail $84,500,000 20 Years 5/18/2010 Bond 62.51%Fail $57,500,000 20 Years 3/8/2011 Supplemental M&O 82.09%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 3/13/2012 Bond 77.73%Pass $53,000,000 20 Years 5/15/2012 Plant 66.56%Pass $2,442,805 10 Years 3/12/2013 Supplemental M&O 79.24%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 3/10/2015 Supplemental M&O 81.92%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 3/14/2017 Supplemental M&O 84.01%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 11/17/2017 Bond 58.45%Fail $110,000,000 20 Years 8/28/2018 Bond 58.44%Fail $86,200,000 20 Years 8/28/2018 Bond 56.89%Fail $13,300,000 20 Years 3/12/2019 Supplemental M&O 76.95%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 3/9/2021 Supplemental M&O 75.01%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 3/8/2022 Plant 80.90%Pass $2,440,000 10 Years 11/8/2022 Bond 57.98%Fail $250,000,000 20 Years 3/14/2023 Supplemental M&O 80.70%Pass $6,800,000 2 Years 11/5/2024 Supplemental M&O 64.61%Pass $8,000,000 2 Years Piper Sandler |5 The District has the following property tax levies for FY 2026. SD 91 Existing Levies Levy Type FY 2026 Amount FY 2026 Rate (per $100,000)Expiration Supplemental Levy(1)$0.00 0.00 FY 2027 Plant Levy(2)$1,742,599 $19.69 FY 2032 Bond Levy N/A N/A N/A Other Levies N/A N/A N/A TOTAL $1,742,599 $19.69 (1) $8,000,000 supplemental levy offset entirely by School Facilities Funds. (2) $2,440,000 plant levy offset by $503,930 of School Facilities Fund and $193,471 of Property Tax Replacement funds. Piper Sandler |6 Levy Calculations and Tax Burden Summary Taxable Market Value Urban Renewal Value Levy Amount Levy Rate (per $100,000) Bond Levy - - Supplemental M&O Levy 8,000,000 90 Plant Levy 2,440,000 28 Total School Levies (before State Funds)10,440,000 118 SFF Offset (HB 292)(8,503,930) (96) Personal Prop Tax Replacement (193,471) (2) Total School Levies (after State Funds)1,742,599 20 Taxpayer Cost (all school levies) Median Home Value(1)398,975$ Less: H.O. Exemption (125,000)$ Median Home Taxable Value 273,975$ $53.95 (1) Zillow Median Home Value for Idaho Falls, Idaho as of January 2025 FY 2026 (ACTUAL) 8,544,412,239 304,368,788 Piper Sandler |7 SD 91 Levy History 204863 205 309346 419424424424424 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 20262025202420232022202120202019201820172016 Historical Levy Rates (per $100,000) Supp. M&O Bond Levy Plant Levy 0 5,000,000 10,000,000 15,000,000 20,000,000 25,000,000 30,000,000 20262025202420232022202120202019201820172016 Historical Levy Amounts Supp M&O Bond Levy Plant Levy Piper Sandler |8 The District’s Taxable market value has experienced significant growth over the past 5 years (13.63% compound growth rate), stronger than the 20-year compound growth rate of 6.90%. Net Taxable Values Fiscal Year Net Taxable Value (w/ URA) 2026 8,848,781,027 2025 8,240,047,262 2024 8,349,148,974 2023 7,006,118,799 2022 5,262,927,747 2021 4,671,289,415 2020 4,230,257,700 2019 3,751,736,830 2018 3,449,058,109 2017 3,256,273,797 2016 3,132,735,306 2015 3,094,028,405 2014 3,054,834,106 2013 3,020,675,054 2012 3,053,506,232 2011 3,072,885,829 2010 3,128,982,810 2009 2,987,990,984 2008 2,645,269,752 2007 2,401,697,364 2006 2,329,809,227 0 1,000,000,000 2,000,000,000 3,000,000,000 4,000,000,000 5,000,000,000 6,000,000,000 7,000,000,000 8,000,000,000 9,000,000,000 10,000,000,000 Idaho Falls SD 91 Historical Market Value Piper Sandler |9 The following is a comparison of Fiscal Year 2026 total property tax rates for Region VI school districts. The statewide average school district property tax rate for Fiscal Year 2026 is $86 per $100,000. Comparison of Region VI School Property Tax Rates 3 6 7 7 9 10 13 18 20 48 51 57 58 84 94 111 124 133 141 0.00 50.00 100.00 150.00 200.00 250.00 300.00 350.00 pe r $ 1 0 0 , 0 0 0 Bond Suppl. M&O Plant BSL All Other Levies (1) (1)"All Other Levies" may include Emergency, Tort or COSSA Levy 02 Recent Legislation –HB 292, 521 Piper Sandler |11 School Facilities Funds (“SFF”) established by HB 292 in 2023, provides State Funding to offset levies in the following order of priority 1.Offset amount levied for bonds (and issued prior to July 1, 2025) 2.Pay back loans from the Public School Facilities Cooperative Funding Program (33-909) 3.Offset amount levied for bonds (and issued on or after July 1, 2025) 4.Offset amount levied for Supplemental Levy (non-permanent) 5.Offset amount levied for Plant Facility Levy 6.Any monies that remain following the payments provided for above may be: i) used for construction of a new school facility, renovation, or maintenance needs; ii) used to secure and make payments on a new school facilities bond; iii) used to make additional payments on existing school facilities bonds; iv) used to make payments on lease-purchase agreements for school facilities; or iii) saved in a reserve account by the school district for future school facility needs School Facilities Funds (2023/2024/2025/2026 Legislation) Piper Sandler |12 Two key items with regard to property tax levies and bonds: 1.Eliminated Bond Levy Equalization –replaced with increased School Facilities Funds (HB 292). Idaho Falls SD 91 has received the following School Facilities Funds distribution: •FY 2024: $3,751,998 •FY 2025: $5,116,405 •FY 2026: $8,503,930 2.HB 521 also created the School Modernization Facilities Fund Program •Idaho Falls SD is received $40.0 million in one-time up front SMFF grant from the SDE in FY 2025. HB 521 Review Piper Sandler |13 The Property Tax Relief provided by the School Facilities Funds has three primary sources of on-going funding: •3.25% of State-wide sales tax collections (does not include on-line sales tax) •$50 million from the tax relief fund plus 20% of annual distribution to the tax relief fund (on-line sales tax) •5/8ths of the Net Income of the Idaho Lottery School Facilities Funds -Continued The FY 2027 distribution is expected to be similar (or slight increase) to FY 2026. School Facility Fund distributions are based on ADA for “brick & mortar” students.$106.20 $140.93 $235.19 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 State Facilities Fund Allocations Based on ADA (in millions) 03 Supplemental Levy Election Planning Piper Sandler | 15 Piper Sandler prepared calculations of the estimated cost per $100,000 for three different supplemental M&O levy amounts “based on current conditions” and compared against the actual cost per $100,000 for FY 2026. Levy Planning Taxable Market Value (for FY 2026 Voted Levies) FY 26 Actual Supplemental Levy Amount Approved $11,000,000 $10,500,000 $10,000,000 $8,000,000 Supplemental Tax Rate Per $100K 124$ 119$ 113$ 90$ Bonds Tax Rate Per $100K -$ -$ -$ -$ Plant Facility Tax Rate Per $100K 28$ 28$ 28$ 28$ Less: SFF (& other) offsets Per $100K (98)$ (98)$ (98)$ (98)$ Net Combined Tax Rate Per $100K 54$ 49$ 43$ 20$ Total Levy Rate Change compared to FY 2026 34$ 29$ 23$ Note: Projected rate calculations assume the same assessed value and SFF contributions as FY 2026. Projected Tax Rates (November 2026 Supplemental Levy Election) $ 8,848,781,027 4500: Public Gifts/Donations to the Schools The Board recognizes and appreciates that organizations and/or individuals may wish to award grants/gifts to Idaho Falls School District. Gifts, donations, grants, or bequests will be accepted and the action recorded, provided the conditions of acceptance do not remove any degree of control of the School District from the Board and will not cause inequitable treatment of any student(s) or student groups(s). The District reserves the right to determine if the grant or gift is appropriate and may request those it deems inappropriate or unsuitable. A gift shall be defined as money, real or personal property, and personal services provided without consideration. Gifts form organizations, community groups, and/or individuals that will benefit the District shall be encouraged by the District administration. Individuals or groups contemplating presenting a gift to a school or the District shall be encouraged to discuss, in advance, with the building principal or the Superintendent what gifts are appropriate and needed. Community groups or individuals may donate equipment to the District. Such equipment shall be added to the District’s inventory, provided it is operative at the time of donation and meets an educational purpose of the District. The District reserves the right to accept or decline any proposed gifts. In determining whether a gift will be accepted, consideration shall be given to District policies, goals, and objectives with particular emphasis on the goal of providing educational opportunities to all students and adherence to the basic principles outlined in Board procedures. To be acceptable, a grant or gift must: • Have a purpose consistent with the beliefs/mission/vision of the District • Not bring undesirable or hidden costs to the District • Place no undesirable restrictions on the Board • Not be inappropriate or harmful to the best education of students • Not be in conflict with any Board policy or state law • Meet the technical or Propositions giving funds, equipment, or materials to the school with a “matching agreement” or restrictions are generally not acceptable. Acceptance of donated equipment or materials may depend upon compliance with the Board’s policy of standardizing materials and equipment in the District which could restrict gifts given by the parent-teacher organizations to individual schools. While the intent of donations will be 20 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D considered, the District reserves the right to modify the use if the needs of the students or the District change. Any person or organization desiring to give a gift or make a donation, grant, or bequest to the Board should contact the appropriate staff member as indicated by Procedure 4500P Public Gifts/Donations to the Schools. Also, where the appropriateness of a gift is in doubt, the Superintendent will refer the matter to the Board for its acceptance or rejection. For example, single gifts of considerable value exhibiting the donor’s name or business shall be considered on an individual basis by the Board. All conditional gifts must be approved by the Board. By acceptance of the grant or gift, the Board makes no commitment to assume financial responsibility for continuation if the grant or gift becomes exhausted. Any grant or gift accepted by the Board or the Superintendent as its executive officer shall become the property of the Board and will be subject to all state and District policies and procedures, including established District pay schedules. Acknowledgement letters must follow IRS guidelines. Legal References Use what is on the ISBA model policy. 21 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D Use of District Property The Board of Trustees recognizes that our facilities are public property managed by the school district and directs the Superintendent or their designee to develop procedures allowing for the public rental of those facilities for non-school-related activities, provided that those activities do not impact instruction or violate Idaho Code. Such rentals shall be consistent with the following provisions: 1. Rentals shall only occur when they do not interfere with any ongoing or scheduled school activities or operations. 2. School-sponsored activities shall be prioritized over public rentals. 3. Rentals shall not interfere with the conduct of the District’s educational program and related activities. 4. Activities shall be appropriate and in the best interest of the District and its students. 5. Require users to abide by District policies and procedures. 6. Persons occupying any facilities shall abide by all applicable Federal, State, Local, and District policies, regulations, and statutes. 7. Rental applications will be denied if the function’s intent is to advance any doctrine subversive to state or federal laws or to advocate social or political change by violent means. The District reserves the right to deny or cancel leases with an individual or organization if any of the requirements of policy or regulation are not satisfied. The Board shall make district property available for use by individuals or organizations that meet the requirements of this policy and procedural guidelines. The procedural guidelines will be in writing and available to all individuals or organizations requesting use of District property. The Superintendent or designee has the authority to charge rates where applicable, establish priorities, determine frequency of use, and grant or deny requests. The Superintendent or designee will annually review the lease rates to determine if a change is deemed necessary. Fees are set by procedural guidelines subject ot Board approval. An increase of 5% or greater must meet the requirements of state law for public announcement and input. This policy governs public use only; Intergovernmental Cooperative Agreements, Joint use Agreements, and Inter-Agency Agreements shall be governed by their own contractual relationships. 22 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D Legal Reference: Idaho Code 33-601, 33-506(1), 63-1311A 23 DRA F T N O T A P P R O V E D